Managed IT vs. In-House IT: Which Delivers Better ROI?

Did you know that 60% of small businesses close within six months of a cyberattack? In today’s digital world, technology is not just a support function—it’s a strategic driver of business success. From cybersecurity to cloud solutions, companies rely on IT to operate efficiently, stay competitive, and protect valuable data. But when it comes to managing IT, there’s a major decision to make: should you build an in-house IT team or outsource to a Managed IT provider?

Both options have their merits, but when it comes to cost, efficiency, security, and long-term ROI, one often delivers greater value than the other. Let’s dive in and compare the two approaches to see which makes the most sense for your business.

Cost Comparison: Understanding the True Investment

One of the biggest factors in the IT debate is cost. Hiring an in-house IT team means committing to salaries, benefits, training, and ongoing certifications—not to mention the expense of purchasing and maintaining hardware, software, and security infrastructure. And if a key team member leaves? Recruiting and training replacements can be a costly disruption.

Let’s take a look at some examples:

The Cost of an In-House IT Team

Hiring a full-time IT professional isn’t cheap. According to Glassdoor:

• IT Support Specialist: $55,000 - $82,000 per year

• Network Administrator: $73,000 - $114,000 per year

• Cybersecurity Specialist: $128,000 - $209,000 per year

• IT Director/Manager:$170,000 - $290,000 per year

On top of salaries, there are additional costs:

• Benefits & Taxes: Add 30-40% of salary per employee.

• Training & Certifications: $3,000 - $10,000 per year, per employee.

• Hardware & Software Costs: $50,000 - $100,000 upfront for servers, software, and security tools.

For a mid-sized business needing a 5-person IT team, you’re looking at $500,000+ per year, and that’s before unexpected repairs or technology upgrades.

Managed IT services, on the other hand, operate on a predictable, fixed-cost model. Instead of hiring multiple specialists in-house, businesses pay a monthly fee for 24/7 access to IT professionals who handle everything from cybersecurity to troubleshooting. There are no surprise costs for system failures, and scaling IT support up or down is seamless—no need for new hires or additional office space.

The Cost of Managed IT Services

Managed IT services typically operate on a fixed monthly fee based on the number of users, devices, and services included. Cost ranges vary by company size, company type, and if they are a 24x7 operation, but common pricing models include:

• Basic IT Support: $75 - $150 per user/month

• Fully Managed IT (including cybersecurity & cloud solutions): $150 - $300 per user/month

• Enterprise-Level IT with 24/7 Monitoring: $300 - $500 per user/month

For a 50-person company, Managed IT could cost $7,500 - $15,000 per month or $90,000 - $180,000 per year—less than half the cost of an in-house team.

Which wins? If cost control is a priority, Managed IT Services provide a more predictable and affordable solution, especially for small and mid-sized businesses.

Performance & Efficiency: Who Solves IT Problems Faster?

When IT issues arise, every second counts. An in-house IT team may be readily available, but their expertise is limited to the skill sets of a few employees. Complex problems—like network failures or cybersecurity threats—might require outside specialists, slowing down resolution times. Additionally, most in-house teams only provide support during business hours, meaning late-night outages or security breaches may not be addressed immediately.

Managed IT providers offer a huge advantage in performance by providing round-the-clock monitoring and rapid response times. They employ a team of specialists in various IT disciplines, ensuring that businesses always have access to the right expertise when they need it. Plus, they leverage AI-powered monitoring and automated issue resolution, preventing minor glitches from becoming major disruptions.

Even tech giants like Google recognize the efficiency of outsourcing IT functions. Despite having over 178,000 employees, Google relies on external IT support to manage high-demand projects. A prime example is the Google AdWords project, a critical revenue driver in 2017. To ensure its seamless operation, Google enlisted more than 1,000 outsourced representatives from over 60 countries. This strategic move allowed them to scale efficiently, maintain high performance, and focus internal resources on innovation rather than routine IT management.

For businesses that rely on seamless IT operations, Managed IT services provide the agility and expertise needed to minimize downtime and maximize efficiency.

Security & Compliance: Reducing Risk in a Digital World

Cybersecurity threats are constantly evolving, and compliance regulations are becoming more complex. In-house IT teams are often stretched thin, struggling to keep up with the latest threat intelligence, security patches, and compliance requirements—especially if cybersecurity isn’t their primary expertise. Without a dedicated security team, businesses face a higher risk of data breaches, ransomware attacks, and regulatory penalties.

Managed IT providers take a proactive approach to security. They implement advanced threat detection systems, real-time monitoring, and industry-best security protocols to protect businesses from cyber threats. They also specialize in compliance management, ensuring companies meet industry regulations like HIPAA, PCI-DSS, CMMC, or GDPR. With Managed IT, security isn’t just an afterthought—it’s a core priority.

Need an IT Audit?
IT Pro Consulting helps businesses strengthen their security posture with comprehensive IT audits. Our experts assess your systems, identify vulnerabilities, and ensure compliance with industry regulations. Whether you need to mitigate risks, prepare for an audit, or enhance your cybersecurity strategy, IT Pro Consulting provides the expertise and actionable insights to keep your business secure.

For companies handling sensitive data or operating in regulated industries, Managed IT provides better protection, lower risk, and peace of mind.

ROI & Business Impact: Where’s the Long-Term Value?

At the end of the day, IT isn’t just about fixing problems—it’s about driving business growth and minimizing risk. Managed IT services often provide higher long-term ROI by reducing unexpected expenses, improving uptime, and keeping businesses ahead of evolving technology trends. Instead of constantly playing catch-up, businesses can focus on innovation and strategic growth while their IT provider ensures systems run smoothly.

That’s not to say in-house IT is obsolete. For businesses with highly specialized technology needs—or those that require direct, on-site control of IT infrastructure—an in-house team might still be the right choice. However, for most companies, Managed IT provides greater flexibility, cost savings, and expertise—making it the clear winner for ROI.

Final Verdict: Which One is Right for You?

If your business values cost efficiency, scalability, advanced security, and 24/7 support, Managed IT Services will likely deliver better ROI than building an in-house team. However, if you require deeply customized systems and want full in-house control, an internal IT team may still be worth the investment.

The key is to align your IT strategy with your business goals. Whether you choose Managed IT or in-house IT, ensuring your technology supports your growth, security, and efficiency is what truly matters.

Schedule a free consultation today and see how Managed IT can reduce costs and boost efficiency.